For many, the idea of troubled teens being forcibly removed from their homes and placed into behavioral programs is something we’ve only seen on reality shows like Scared Straight. While those shows often exaggerated events for dramatic effect, the harsh reality is that these institutions have existed for decades, and the stories of the young people subjected to them are rarely told. F*ckUps Anonymous, based on creator Joe Tierney’s personal experiences, brings this dark and disturbing world into focus. Directed by Kat Whalen and starring Sarah Jeffery and Andrew Michael Fama, the pilot is an unsettling yet darkly comedic look at a school that might just be worse than hell itself.
The institution in question was eventually shut down in 2014 due to widespread allegations of abuse, mistreatment, and dangerous policies. FckUps Anonymous* plays like the Addams Family meets the brutality of a prison drama, flipping expectations on their head while exposing the cruelty of a system meant to “fix” troubled youth. The show raises a critical question: Do these institutions actually help, or do they cause more harm than good? The abusive tactics used by staff members, often turning the kids against one another, make you wonder if any real rehabilitation is happening at all. In many ways, the show parallels the prison system, where reform can sometimes do more damage than good.
In my own experience, I’ve always questioned the effectiveness of these programs. The idea of a child being ripped from their bed in the middle of the night, thrown into a van, and locked away in a place where both staff and peers impose a twisted hierarchy of power is horrifying. While F*ckUps Anonymous is filled with humor and sharp writing, the underlying message is chilling—there’s an entire generation of kids who have endured these programs, and many are still dealing with the psychological scars.
It’s no surprise that F*ckUps Anonymous won the Best Pilot award at SXSW. It’s an essential show, shedding light on a broken system that has long gone unchecked. These programs disproportionately cater to wealthy families who can afford to send their children away, while lower-income families have no choice but to navigate their children’s struggles on their own. And yet, for many, the streets pose just as much, if not more, danger than these so-called “treatment” programs.
This show ignites an important conversation: How should we approach troubled youth? Should we allow children the space to find their own way, or does society’s growing culture of overprotection lead to even harsher consequences? F*ckUps Anonymous doesn’t just tell a story—it challenges the very notion of behavioral reform. If even one parent watches this and reconsiders sending their child to such a program, then it has already done something meaningful.
4.5/5
Created and Written by: Joe Tierney
Director: Kat Whalen
Cast: Sarah Jeffery, Andrew Michael Fama, Debbie Campbell, Lexi Simonsen, Bob Gallagher, Marvin St-Jean, Stephen Gray, Timothy Griffin Allan
Comments